Is Phosphine-3 Proof of Aliens on Venus?

No. 

I’ll just get right to the point.

No doubt you’ve heard the news, but if you haven’t a paper was release via NATURE about a team of astronomers who have isolated a phosphine absorption line (PH3) in their spectral analysis of Venus, using two different telescopes, several different reduction methods and measurable uncertainties. The amount of PH3 is quite small (20 parts per billion) but why it’s there at all poses the question – how?

PH3 has only recently been considered as a potential biomarker but only for rocky planets, as it can occur naturally in the gas giants, and indeed does in Jupiter and Saturn. Typically here on Earth, it’s found as a byproduct of life and is found (for example) in penguin poo.

We shouldn’t immediately conclude there are penguins on Venus of course, and to do so would be jumping the gun. PH3 can be produced by a number of natural methods, it’s just that those methods are unlikely on Venus’ hot, hostile landscape. If life is indeed the source, it may be cloud-based microbial life but even the paper itself urges scepticism here:

“… we emphasize that the detection of PH3 is not robust evidence for life, only for anomalous and unexplained chemistry. There are substantial conceptual problems for the idea of life in Venus’s clouds…”

In any case you are likely to be bombarded with news articles suggesting this possibility so bear in mind a few things. Firstly, we’ve had news stories like this before even from NASA where they’ve turned out to be false. Contaminated meteorite samples were once reported as alien bacteria, and who can forget the “arsenic based life” story which turned out to be a flawed conclusion and unrepeatable by other researchers.

It’s quite possible that despite the astronomers best efforts here, a transition from another molecule is being detected at the wrong wavelength through shift or noise in the data. Their methods appear fairly robust but it remains to be seen whether it can be repeated by other researchers or is a “double false-positive”. The absorption signature may even stem from Earth – remember the time a mysterious deep space radio signal ended up being an astronomer microwaving noodles in the next room?

The next step is trying to detect PH3 absorption from other telescopes, preferably ones in space. Only after the finding is confirmed do we then form a crack team of steampunk robots and drones to go and give Venus a closer whiff. Like all space fans though, any further exploration of Venus is welcome – life or not. Venus may tell us more about our future here on Earth.

Dylan O’Donnell 

 

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.

Countdown To Mars Opposition

(Photo by Damien Peach, 2018)             

Weather Update (For Jupiter)

Jupiter has a new storm outbreak in the Northern hemisphere which is causing some excitement for Jupiter fans. The planet is still quite good to image this month, appearing high overhead and still quite large. The storm is best seen in Infrared (IR) and specifically the Methane band however you would need a very sensitive…

Bintel Astronomy Livestream REPLAY

Testing, testing, 1, 2, 3… is this mic on? We’re going to try to broadcast views from space live this evening and see what happens! Join us or watch the replay using the links here.            

Star Adventurer 2i Pro Kit Announced!

The upgraded version of the very popular Star Adventurer star tracking mount for DSLRs and small telescopes has been announced. Appealing to the travelling nightscape and wide field astrophotographer, this new iteration of the Star Adventurer features WiFi app control that means the mount also doubles as a very capable motion/pan time-lapse intervalometer as well…

Contactless Pickup Now Available (Sydney)

If you want the expedience of buying something straight from our Sydney store without all the bother of risking exposure to potentially-infectious pathogens and their human couriers, we’re happy to help. Now if you choose “Contactless Pickup” from the checkout of our online store, we will prepare your order and wait for your phone call…

Comet C/2020 F3 (NEOWISE) Comes Downunder!

Well, we were grumpy before but it appears that Comet NEOWISE has finally graced our skies for those with clear enough views to the western horizon. The comet is reportedly dimming and also competing against the Sun and the first quarter moon. Initial observations from Australia report that it’s not quite naked eye. Hopefully this…

World Record Light

On June 21st lovers of the night sky are invited to participate in a mass survey to help map light pollution across the Earth. Bintel are sponsoring this event organised by the Australian Dark Sky Alliance (ADSA) with a give-away of a new StarSense Explorer 130DX Telescope. This is one among many other giveaways for…

Adam Block – PixInsight Tutorials

Adam Block is an award winning astrophotographer from the USA who shares much of his skills via his website and recently, YouTube. His latest series focusses on the Batch Processing tool within PixInsight but is an excellent resource for those willing to dive deep into post processing with PixInsight. There are 10 parts so far….

Whale Watching Season Begins!

It’s hard to believe some people use telescopes and binoculars for something other than off-planet targets, but it’s true. A good many of our customers are wildlife and nature enthusiasts and Milky Way season is also Whale watching season. Whales begin their migration along the east coast of Australia and watching them surge out of…

How to Choose the Best Telescope & Camera Combination

We have a lot of different telescopes and cameras and they aren’t all suited to each other. Depending on what you want to shoot and how certain telescope and camera combinations are better or worse. For planets you need a magnifier like a Barlow, but for big galaxies or nebula you need a wide field…

Menu